Skip to content
Free shipping on qualifying orders
Cain'sBedding & Waterbeds

How to Choose a Mattress

There's no single "best" mattress — only the best one for how you sleep. Here's how the main types actually differ, so you can narrow it down fast.

Start with three questions

  1. What position do you sleep in? Side sleepers usually want more cushion for hips and shoulders; back and stomach sleepers usually want firmer support.
  2. Do you sleep hot? Some materials trap heat; others stay cool.
  3. Do you share the bed? Motion isolation matters if your partner moves.

Hold those answers while you read.

The types, honestly compared

Memory foam

Contours closely and isolates motion beautifully — you barely feel a partner move. The trade-off is heat: traditional memory foam can sleep warm, which is why gel-infused versions (like Spring Air's Coastal Dreams) exist to pull heat away. Great for side sleepers and couples who want quiet, cradling support.

Innerspring

The classic coil bed. Bouncy, breathable, and cooler-sleeping, with strong edge support and a familiar feel — and usually the friendliest price. Bemco's lineup is a good example. Best if you want a traditional, supportive, well-ventilated bed.

Hybrid

Coils for support and airflow, foam on top for comfort — the "best of both" that dominates the market now. Spring Air's MAXLife hybrids pair independent coils (motion separation) with a plush hand-tufted top. A safe choice for most people, especially couples who want support and pressure relief.

Latex

Responsive, durable, and naturally cooler than memory foam, with a buoyant "on top of the bed" feel rather than a sink-in hug. A great pick if you want longevity and a cooler, springier feel.

Waterbed (flotation)

Adjustable temperature (the heater) and even, pressure-relieving support that conforms to you. Modern waveless and dual options remove the old "sloshing" problem. Ideal if you have pressure-point or joint discomfort, or you just love the feel — see our Waterbed Buyer's Guide.

Match it to you

If you… Consider
Sleep on your side / want pressure relief Memory foam, gel memory foam, or a waterbed
Sleep hot Gel memory foam, latex, innerspring, or a waterbed (temperature-controlled)
Share the bed and want quiet Memory foam, or a hybrid with independent coils
Want a traditional, supportive, cooler bed Innerspring or hybrid
Want longevity and a springy feel Latex or hybrid
Have joint/back pressure issues Waterbed or quality memory foam

Don't forget the base

An adjustable base (like the Leggett & Platt Simplicity) works with most foam and hybrid mattresses and changes everything for reading, relaxing, snoring, and circulation. If you're between a flat bed and an upgrade, the base is often the better spend.

The 20-minute shortcut

Tell us your sleep position, whether you run hot, and your budget — we'll hand you two or three to compare instead of twenty. That's the advantage of a specialist over a big-box wall of identical white rectangles.

FAQ

Firm or soft for back pain? Usually medium-firm with good contouring — too soft lets hips sag, too firm creates pressure points. Side sleepers trend a touch softer.

How long should a mattress last? Many years with quality construction; replace when you wake up stiff or see sagging. Waterbeds and latex often go the longest.

Is a hybrid better than memory foam? Not "better" — cooler and bouncier, with more support. Memory foam isolates motion and cradles more. It's about preference.

Can any mattress go on an adjustable base? Most foam and hybrid beds can; very stiff innersprings may not flex well. Ask us about a specific model.


Browse Mattresses, Memory Foam, Spring Air & MAXLife, or Adjustable Bases — or call (877) 474-9196.

Shop related

Mattresses

Shop Mattresses

Questions? We're happy to help.

Call (877) 474-9196 or visit the Hartford, IL showroom — Mon–Sat 10 AM–6 PM.

Accessibility

Profiles

Text size

Display